Bitcoin 
Ethereum 
Tether 
XRP 
BNB 
Solana 
USDC 
Dogecoin 
Cardano 
TRON 
In a landmark decision that reverberates across the digital asset landscape, a U.S. federal court has permanently barred the Department of the Treasury’s Office of Foreign Assets Control (OFAC) from reimposing sanctions on Tornado Cash, a decentralized cryptocurrency mixer. This ruling not only marks a significant victory for privacy advocates and the open-source community but also sets a precedent in the ongoing debate over the regulation of decentralized technologies.
The Genesis of the Legal Battle
Tornado Cash, launched in 2019, is an open-source, non-custodial protocol on the Ethereum blockchain that allows users to obfuscate the origin and destination of cryptocurrency transactions, enhancing privacy. In August 2022, OFAC sanctioned Tornado Cash, alleging it was used to launder over $7 billion in virtual currency, including funds stolen by North Korea’s Lazarus Group. This action marked the first time the U.S. government sanctioned a piece of open-source software rather than a person or organization.
The sanctions sparked immediate backlash from the crypto community, civil liberties organizations, and developers, who argued that penalizing code infringes on free speech and sets a dangerous precedent for open-source software. Six Tornado Cash users, with support from Coinbase, filed a lawsuit challenging the sanctions, asserting that OFAC overstepped its authority under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA).
The Court’s Rationale
In November 2024, the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that OFAC had exceeded its statutory authority, stating that Tornado Cash’s immutable smart contracts are not “property” and thus not subject to sanctions under IEEPA. The court emphasized that these smart contracts are self-executing code that cannot be owned or controlled, even by their creators.
Despite this ruling, OFAC attempted to sidestep a final judgment by voluntarily delisting Tornado Cash in March 2025, claiming the case was moot. However, on April 28, 2025, U.S. District Judge Robert Pitman rejected this argument, issuing a permanent injunction preventing OFAC from reimposing sanctions on Tornado Cash. Judge Pitman criticized the Treasury’s maneuvering, stating that the agency’s actions were an attempt to avoid an adverse judgment and that the plaintiffs deserved a definitive legal resolution.
Implications for the Crypto Industry
This ruling has far-reaching implications for the crypto industry, particularly for developers and users of decentralized protocols. It reinforces the principle that publishing open-source code is protected speech and that developers should not be held liable for how others use their code. The decision also underscores the challenges regulators face in applying existing legal frameworks to decentralized technologies that lack a central authority or control.
Paul Grewal, Chief Legal Officer at Coinbase, hailed the ruling as a “historic win for crypto and all who care about defending liberty,” emphasizing the importance of protecting innovation and privacy in the digital age.
Ongoing Legal Challenges
While the court’s decision is a significant victory for Tornado Cash and the broader crypto community, legal challenges remain. Roman Storm and Roman Semenov, co-founders of Tornado Cash, still face criminal charges in the U.S. for allegedly facilitating money laundering and sanctions violations. Storm’s trial is scheduled for July 2025. The DeFi Education Fund has petitioned the White House to drop these charges, arguing that prosecuting developers for the misuse of their code could stifle innovation and set a dangerous precedent.
A Turning Point for Decentralized Technologies
The court’s ruling marks a turning point in the regulation of decentralized technologies. It highlights the need for updated legal frameworks that can effectively address the unique characteristics of blockchain-based systems without stifling innovation or infringing on individual rights. As decentralized finance (DeFi) and other blockchain applications continue to grow, regulators and lawmakers will need to carefully balance the goals of preventing illicit activity with the imperative to foster technological advancement and protect civil liberties.
In conclusion, the permanent injunction against OFAC’s sanctions on Tornado Cash is a milestone in the ongoing evolution of digital asset regulation. It affirms the rights of developers and users in the decentralized ecosystem and sets a precedent for how open-source protocols are treated under the law. As the crypto industry continues to mature, this case will serve as a reference point in the dialogue between innovation and regulation.
